[
 {
  "ingredient": "Acetylated lanolin",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Acetylated lanolin alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "Fulton traced the reaction to the cetyl acetate additive, not to the acetylated lanolin itself."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Anhydrous lanolin",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-1*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Lanolin alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-2*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Lanolin oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-1*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 16 lanolin (Solulan 16)",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "Fulton linked the reaction to non-lanolin additives in the raw material (ceteth-16, oleth-16, steareth-16)."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 75 lanolin",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Laneth-10",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PPG 12 PEG 65 lanolin oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Lanolins and derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Caprylic acid",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Capric acid",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Lauric acid",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "Lauric acid derivatives such as laureth-4 were named among the major offenders."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Myristic acid",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Palmitic acid",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Stearic acid",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2-3*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Eicosanoic acid",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Behenic acid",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ascorbyl palmitate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Behenyl erucate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Butyl stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cetyl acetate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cetyl ester NF",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cetyl palmitate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Decyl oleate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Di (2 ethylhexyl) succinate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Dioctyl malate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Dioctyl succinate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Diisopropyl adipate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Diisopropyl dimerate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ethylhexyl palmitate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ethylhexyl pelargonate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isodecyl oleate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2-3*",
  "irritancy_grade": "1-2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isopropyl isostearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "5",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "A close cousin of isopropyl myristate; Fulton lists this family as comedogenic."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isopropyl linolate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isopropyl myristate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "5",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "Named by Fulton as one of the major offenders to use with caution in skin care products."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isopropyl palmitate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isostearyl neopentanoate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isostearyl isostearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Myristyl lactate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Myristyl myristate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "5",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "A close cousin of isopropyl myristate; Fulton lists this family as comedogenic."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Octyldodecyl stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Octyldodecyl stearoyl stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Stearyl heptanoate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Tridecyl neopentanoate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Fatty acids and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "SD alcohol 40",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isopropyl alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Myristyl alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "4",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cetyl alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Isocetyl alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "4",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cetearyl alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Oleyl alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Stearyl alcohol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cetearyl alcohol + ceteareth 20",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ceteareth-20",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Propylene glycol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Butylene glycol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Hexylene glycol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-2*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0-1",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PG caprylate/caprate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PG dicaprylate/caprate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PG dipelargonate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PG laurate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PG monostearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0-1",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ethylene glycol monostearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Glucose glutamate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sorbitol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sorbitan laurate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1-2*",
  "irritancy_grade": "1-2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sorbitan sesquinoleate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-1*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sorbitan oleate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sorbitan stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sorbitan isostearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1-2*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 40 sorbitan laurate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Polysorbate 20",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Polysorbate 80",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Glycerin",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Glycereth-26",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Glyceryl-3-diisostearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Glyceryl stearate NSE",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "Plain (non-self-emulsifying) glyceryl stearate. If the label says glyceryl stearate SE, the SE grade of 3 applies instead."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Glyceryl stearate SE",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "SE (self-emulsifying) grades contain added sodium or potassium stearate, which made the mix more comedogenic than plain glyceryl stearate."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Glyceryl tricapylo/caprate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": "Matched to caprylic/capric triglyceride, the current label name for this ingredient."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Behenyl triglyceride",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Pentaerythrital tetra isostearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Pentaerythrital tetra capra/caprylate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Wheat germ glyceride",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Polyglyceryl-3-diisostearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Polyethylene glycol (PEG 400)",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sucrose distearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sucrose stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 120 methyl glucose dioleate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 8 stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 20 stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 100 stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "324",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 100 distearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 150 distearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 200 dilaurate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Laureth-4",
  "comedogenic_grade": "5",
  "irritancy_grade": "4",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Named by Fulton as one of the major offenders (a lauric acid derivative)."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Laureth-23",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Steareth-2",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Steareth-10",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Steareth-20",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Steareth-100",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Oleth-3",
  "comedogenic_grade": "5",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Oleth-5",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Oleth-10",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Oleth-20",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Oleth-3 phosphate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Triacetin",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PPG 5 ceteth 10 phosphate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PPG 2 myristyl propionate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PPG 10 cetyl ether",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PPG 30 cetyl ester",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PPG 50 cetyl ester",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 78 glyceryl monococoate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 8 castor oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 40 castor oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Polypentaerythrital tetralaurate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Alcohols, sugars and their derivatives",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Candelilla wax",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Waxes",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Carnauba wax",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Waxes",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ceresin wax",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Waxes",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Beeswax",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-2*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Waxes",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Some commercial batches were more comedogenic than others, suggesting contaminants."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Lanolin wax",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Waxes",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Jojoba oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-2*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Waxes",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Some commercial batches were more comedogenic than others, suggesting contaminants."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sulfated jojoba oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Waxes",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Modifying the wax (sulfation) made it able to react."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Emulsifying wax NF",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0-2*",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Waxes",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Irritancy depended on how much cetearyl alcohol the wax contained."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Carboxymethylcellulose",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Carboxypropylcellulose",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Hydroxypropylcellulose",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Magnesium aluminum silicate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Carbomer 940",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Bentonite",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Kaolin",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Talc",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PVP",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Thickeners",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cocoa butter",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Fulton notes cocoa and coconut butter have long been known to cause pomade acne, confirmed in the rabbit ear test."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Coconut butter",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Fulton tested coconut butter, the solid form of coconut fat; on labels it appears as Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil. Fulton notes cocoa and coconut butter have long been known to cause pomade acne."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Hydrogenated vegetable oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Fulton suggests it contains residual irritating lipids."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sesame oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3(1)",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Corn oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Avocado oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3(2)",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Evening primrose oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Mink oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3(2)",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Soybean oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Shark liver oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cotton seed oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Peanut oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Olive oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2(1)",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sandalwood seed oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Almond oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2(1)",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Apricot kernel oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2(1)",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Hydrogenated polyisobutane",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Castor oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Hydrogenated castor oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Chaulmoogra oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Babassu oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Squalane",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Maleated soybean oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Safflower oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sunflower oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Mineral oil",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Oils",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Fulton: some sources are acceptable, others are not."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #3",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #4",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #6",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #7",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #9",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #17",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #19",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #21",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #27",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #30",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #33",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #36",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": "Grade 3 in mineral oil, 1 in propylene glycol and 0 in PEG 400 (Fulton Table II): the base matters."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "D&C red #40",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ultramarine violet",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Iron oxides",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Carmine",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Titanium dioxide",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Pigments",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Simethicone",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Silicones",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Dimethicone",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Silicones",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cyclomethicone",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Silicones",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Cholesterol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Sterols",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Soya sterol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Sterols",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 5 soya sterol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Sterols",
  "source_page": "325",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "PEG 10 soya sterol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "1",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Sterols",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Choleth 24",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Sterols",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sterol esters",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Sterols",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Phytantriol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Sterols",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "A & D additive",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Vitamins and herbs",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Tocopherol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0-3*",
  "irritancy_grade": "0-3*",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Vitamins and herbs",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": "Fulton calls tocopherol a follicular irritant and advises against it on acne-prone skin; tocopheryl acetate scored 0."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Tocopheryl acetate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Vitamins and herbs",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Black walnut extract",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Vitamins and herbs",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Papain",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Vitamins and herbs",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Chamomile extract",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Vitamins and herbs",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Vitamin A palmitate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1-3*",
  "irritancy_grade": "1-3*",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Vitamins and herbs",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Panthenol",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Vitamins and herbs",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Methyl paraben",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Preservatives and additives",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Propylparaben",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Preservatives and additives",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Phenoxyethyl paraben",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Preservatives and additives",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Allantoin",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Preservatives and additives",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sodium hyaluronate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Preservatives and additives",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Chondroitin sulfate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Preservatives and additives",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Precipitated sulfur",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Preservatives and additives",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Water-soluble sulfur",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Preservatives and additives",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Octyl dimethyl PABA",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Oxybenzone",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Octyl methoxycinnamate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Octyl salicylate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Acetone",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ethyl ether",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Diethylene glycol monoethyl ether",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Ethylene glycol monomethyl ether (EGME)",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Xylene",
  "comedogenic_grade": "4",
  "irritancy_grade": "3",
  "tier": "high",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": "A solvent; Fulton found it comedogenic and irritating."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Lithium stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Magnesium stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Zinc oxide",
  "comedogenic_grade": "1",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Zinc stearate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Triethanolamine",
  "comedogenic_grade": "2",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low-moderate",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": "Fulton found triethanolamine more comedogenic than aminomethylpropylamine."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Stearic acid:TEA",
  "comedogenic_grade": "3",
  "irritancy_grade": "2",
  "tier": "moderate",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": "The stearic acid and triethanolamine pair used in cold creams; every ratio tested was comedogenic."
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Amoniomethylpropinate",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Sodium PCA",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 },
 {
  "ingredient": "Hydrolyzed animal protein",
  "comedogenic_grade": "0",
  "irritancy_grade": "0",
  "tier": "low",
  "group": "Miscellaneous",
  "source_page": "326",
  "note": ""
 }
]